Search Reynolds Lake Oconee Real Estate Listings

Register for free for full access to all Reynolds Lake Oconee homes for sale. You'll also unlock access to free search tools, including the ability to save listings and property searches. You can also sign up for custom-tailored searches that send new listings directly to your email address. Check out our how-to page for more info.

  • Price$2,329,000
  • Beds5
  • Baths4
  • SQ. Feet6,292
  • Acres1.27
  • Built2023

110 S Cay Drive, Milledgeville

JAW DROPPING FARMHOUSE HOME ON LAKE SINCLAIR!! This one is special - you probably hear that about a lot of homes but this one truly is remarkable, plenty of space but not overwhelming. Deep water at the end of the dock, great view, AMAZING location (minutes to Publix, Kroger and restaurants), fully upgraded with TONS of custom pieces. Walk in and you're greeted with a warm and cozy interior featuring ship lap walls, a true reclaimed brick fireplace, white oak interior beams, 7" European White Oak Engineering flooring and more! Spacious living room right upon entry - the dining room is just off the living space. The kitchen is what lake living dreams are made of! All on the lakeside of the house with a sink in the island overlooking the lake, an eat-in breakfast area, stainless steel appliances, under cabinet lighting, soft close cabinetry, walk in pantry and quartz countertops. Bright and airy while showcasing the water. Step outside and you've got a MASSIVE covered porch with tongue and groove ceilings, a porch swing, dining table and sitting area with a TV. The master suite is on the waterside of the home and has a cypress tongue and groove ceiling, walk-in closet with a barn door, tile floors in the bathroom with a double vanity, walk-in tile shower and a free standing tub. Also on the main level, you have a guest bedroom with an additional tile shower that has a direct door as well as a barn door in the hall, a dreamy farmhouse style laundry room and an office space/flex space. Upstairs you have another 2 bedrooms that are GENEROUSLY sized with king beds and plenty of space for additional furniture and a full bath with a tub shower featuring a tile surround and tile floors. Downstairs is where the party is at! Another laundry room on this level, a TRUE theater room, big living space with coffered ceilings, a big storage room, another bedroom and another full bath... ALSO another kitchen setup equipped with a dishwasher, island, refrigerator, sink and TONS of cabinetry. The basement patio is finished off with a nice under deck system making it perfect for enjoying regardless of the weather and also has a new hot tub. It's a super level walk to the dock and there's a new built in fire pit in the yard - perfect for enjoying fires by the water! Double boathouse at the shoreline. Some other features to note are: new seawall, sprinkler system is installed, tons of custom wood work, 2 car attached garage, and more! Let's get you sold on this AMAZING home!!!

Essential Information

  • MLS® #70967
  • Price$2,329,000
  • Bedrooms5
  • Bathrooms4.00
  • Full Baths4
  • Square Footage6,292
  • Acres1.27
  • Year Built2023
  • TypeResidential
  • Sub-TypeSingle Family, Lake Comm Home
  • StyleRustic, Craftsman Style
  • StatusACTIVE
  • Lake AccessPrivate Access
  • Dock ViewDouble Stall Boathouse

Amenities

  • FeaturesBoat House, Hot Tub, Irrigation System, Lake Pump, Paved Driveway, Firepit
  • Garages2 Car Attached
  • Is WaterfrontYes
  • WaterfrontLakefront, Lake View, Mid Cove

Exterior

  • ExteriorHardy Board
  • Exterior FeaturesCovered Patio, Covered Porch
  • Lot DescriptionGentle Slope
  • RoofAsphalt/Comp Shingle

Listing Details

  • Listing OfficeKeller Williams Realty Lake Oconee

Community Information

  • Address110 S Cay Drive
  • AreaLake Sinclair Area
  • SubdivisionNONE
  • CityMilledgeville
  • CountyPutnam
  • StateGA
  • Zip Code31024-0000

Interior

  • InteriorTile, Vinyl, Wood
  • Interior FeaturesSmoke Detector, Window Treatments, Primary on Main
  • AppliancesBuilt in Microwave, Dishwasher, Dryer, Range, Refrigerator, Vent Hood, Washer
  • CoolingCentral Electric
  • Has BasementYes
  • BasementFull Finished Basement
  • FireplaceYes
  • FireplacesMasonry Fireplace, Ventless Gas Fireplace
  • Stories2 Story

Additional Information

  • Date ListedMay 9th, 2026
  • ZoningResidential
Please provide a valid email address.

© 2016 Lake Country GA MLS. All rights reserved. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program of LCGAMLS and is exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information provided is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Date last updated: Monday, May 18th, 2026.