Search Reynolds Lake Oconee Real Estate Listings
Register for free for full access to all Reynolds Lake Oconee homes for sale. You'll also unlock access to free search tools, including the ability to save listings and property searches. You can also sign up for custom-tailored searches that send new listings directly to your email address. Check out our how-to page for more info.
- Price$450,000
- Beds5
- Baths3½
- SQ. Feet3,162
- Acres0.25
- Built1920
205 W Sumter Street, Eatonton
Historic Victorian Home with Renovated Guesthouse | Downtown Eatonton -- Step into Southern charm and historic elegance with this stunning Victorian home, just steps from the courthouse and within walking distance to restaurants, shops, events, and the Uncle Remus Museum. The main house features a large covered front porch, original heart pine floors, four fireplaces with original mantles, and spacious, light-filled rooms throughout. The remodeled kitchen boasts Florentine tile flooring, a large island, granite countertops, and stainless steel appliances, while the primary suite offers a renovated bath with tiled shower, double vanity, and granite countertops. A wide Southern-style staircase leads to a carpeted bonus room and three additional bedrooms. Relax or entertain on the wraparound back deck, perfect for summer evenings or morning coffee. The 608 sq ft guesthouse is fully renovated with Duralux waterproof flooring, full kitchen with stainless steel appliances, updated bath, and climate-controlled garage, providing excellent income potential or flexible living space. Recognized by the Eatonton Historic Preservation Commission with a "Keeping It Historic" award, this home blends historic character with modern updates, including: new HVAC with ductwork, updated plumbing, gutters with historic-style downspouts, new insulation, electrical upgrades with 15+ circuits, updated lighting, roofs approx. 9 years old, and two water heaters (guesthouse approx. 9 years old). Enjoy quiet small-town living with easy access to all amenities, while owning a move-in ready totally electric historic home with income-producing potential.
Essential Information
- MLS® #70261
- Price$450,000
- Bedrooms5
- Bathrooms3.50
- Full Baths3
- Half Baths1
- Square Footage3,162
- Acres0.25
- Year Built1920
- TypeResidential
- Sub-TypeSingle Family, Residential Home
- StyleTraditional, Victorian
- StatusACTIVE
- Lake AccessNone
Amenities
- FeaturesFenced Partially, Guest House, Paved Driveway, Paved Walkway
- Garages1 Car Attached, Garage
- WaterfrontNone
Exterior
- ExteriorOther, Wood Siding
- Exterior FeaturesCovered Porch, Deck
- Lot DescriptionLevel
- RoofAsphalt/Comp Shingle
Community Information
- Address205 W Sumter Street
- AreaCity Limits
- SubdivisionNONE
- CityEatonton
- CountyPutnam
- StateGA
- Zip Code31024
Interior
- InteriorCarpet, Tile, Wood
- Interior FeaturesSmoke Detector, Primary on Main
- AppliancesBuilt in Microwave, Dishwasher, Range, StainlessSteel Appliances
- HeatingCentral, Electric
- CoolingCentral Electric
- Has BasementYes
- BasementCrawl Space
- FireplaceYes
- FireplacesMultiple Fireplace
- Stories2 Story
Additional Information
- Date ListedFebruary 10th, 2026
- ZoningResidential
© 2016 Lake Country GA MLS. All rights reserved. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program of LCGAMLS and is exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information provided is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Date last updated: Saturday, February 14th, 2026.
















































